1937 Dick Tracy R41

1937 Dick Tracy R41

The 1937 Dick Tracy Cards (R41) were issued by the Walter H. Johnson Candy Co., located in Chicago, Ill.  The set contains 144 cards that were sold in packs of Dick Tracy Caramels.  Cards measure 2 3/8" x 2 7/8" and have framed color fronts with card number and scene title below.  The card backs contain episode number and title, along with a detailed storyline.  In the 1980's there was a major find of mint condition cards for #'s 121-144, which greatly lowered the price for that sequence of cards.

CLICK HERE if you want to sell your 1937 Dick Tracy R41 cards.

1937 Dick Tracy Almost Complete Set
View All + Want
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
 $2,440 
$1,952 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $2,340 
$1,872 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good+ - 3.5
 $1,820 
$1,456 after 20% discount
1
View Close + Cart
#2 Big Boy Awaits Tracy
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.45
1
View Close + Cart
#3 Texie Takes Command
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#4 Big Boy Packs Up
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
$5.75
2
View Close + Cart
#5 Tracy Overhears Conversation
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$3.50
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.45
1
View Close + Cart
#6 Texie on the Spot
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
Authentic
$1.70
1
View Close + Cart
#7 Tracy Questions the Gardener
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
$24.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.70
1
View Close + Cart
#8 Pat Shadows Suspect
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
#9 Tracy Aboard the Alonia
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$8.00
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$4.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.70
1
View Close + Cart
#10 Big Boy Eliminates Becky
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$12.00
2
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.50
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$1.50
2
View Close + Cart
#11 Big Boy Caught in the Act
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.50
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$5.75
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.75
1
View Close + Cart
#13 Mucelli and His Gang
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
$24.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$7.25
1
View Close + Cart
#14 Junior Stumbles on Clue
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#15 Junior Refuses to Talk
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.50
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.25
3
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$1.60
1
View Close + Cart
#16 Junior is Chloroformed
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$7.75
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.50
1
View Close + Cart
#17 Preparing for Torture
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
#19 Gangland Bullets Get Tracy
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#20 Suspected of Shooting Tracy
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
#21 Junior Goes to Jail
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$3.50
1
View Close + Cart
#22 Dick Tracy Comes Back
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$4.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.70
1
View Close + Cart
#23 To Prove Junior's Innocence
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$12.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.50
2
View Close + Cart
#24 Tracy Suddenly Vanishes
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$16.00
1
View Close + Cart
#25 Mucelli is Fooled
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$9.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$4.00
2
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$2.60
1
View Close + Cart
#26 Junior Still in Jail
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
$20.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$5.75
2
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.75
1
View Close + Cart
#27 Junior Dashed to Safety
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.45
1
View Close + Cart
#28 Junior Goes Hungry
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$6.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$1.90
3
View Close + Cart
#29 Surprise Awakening
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$12.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.00
2
View Close + Cart
#30 Two Men and Woman
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$5.25
1
View Close + Cart
Good+ - 2.5
$4.25
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$2.30
1
View Close + Cart
#31 Junior Held His Breath
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.00
2
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.50
1
View Close + Cart
#32 The Doors Were Locked
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
2
View Close + Cart
#33 Junior Runs Into Tracy
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.50
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$3.25
1
View Close + Cart
#34 The Gang Gets Nervous
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
$3.25
3
View Close + Cart
#35 Tracy Takes Fall
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5
$12.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.45
2
View Close + Cart
#36 Through Secret Tunnel
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5
$13.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$4.00
2
View Close + Cart
#37 He Raised His Gun to Fire
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$7.25
2
View Close + Cart
#38 Buggs Gets Instructions
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#39 Tracy Turns Cab Driver
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
$5.50
1
View Close + Cart
#40 Buggs Hailed the Cab
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$5.75
1
View Close + Cart
Good+ - 2.5
$4.50
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.75
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$1.60
1
View Close + Cart
#41 Sudden Departure
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$7.25
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#42 Still Hanging On
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$8.00
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$4.00
1
View Close + Cart
#43 Welcome Surprise
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
#44 Buggs Had Them Covered
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#45 The Reflection in the Mirror
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.50
2
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.75
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$2.45
1
View Close + Cart
#46 The Trapdoor in the Floor
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$7.25
1
View Close + Cart
#47 Lie Detectograph
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
$5.75
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$3.25
1
View Close + Cart
#48 The Hero of the Hour
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.50
2
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.75
1
View Close + Cart
#49 Steve and Old Hank Steele
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$6.75
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$4.50
2
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$2.90
1
View Close + Cart
#50 Hank Steele's Story
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$9.75
1
View Close + Cart
Good+ - 2.5
$5.25
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$4.25
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$1.85
1
View Close + Cart
#51 Steve Starts Travelling
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good+ - 3.5
$8.25
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$7.25
1
View Close + Cart
#52 Tracy Leaves Town
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
#53 Steve Gets Good News
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
2
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$3.50
1
View Close + Cart
#56 Stowaways Caught
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$12.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$5.25
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.50
2
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$2.30
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$1.50
1
View Close + Cart
#57 Cold Brakeman
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$8.50
2
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$5.75
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.75
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$1.60
2
View Close + Cart
#59 An Important Post Card
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$18.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$4.50
1
View Close + Cart
#60 Watching the Mail
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5
$13.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$3.25
2
View Close + Cart
#61 Under the Wheels
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$7.25
1
View Close + Cart
#64 Tracy in the Air
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Poor - 1
$3.00
1
View Close + Cart
#65 The Dead Mailman
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
$5.50
1
View Close + Cart
#67 Queer Hiding Place
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent+ - 5.5
$18.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$3.50
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.45
1
View Close + Cart
#68 Off the Scent
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
#69 Steve Meets Friend
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint+ - 6.5
$33.50
1
View Close + Cart
#70 The Stolen Hand Car
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$5.75
2
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$3.75
2
View Close + Cart
#72 Trapped on the Trestle
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Good - 2
$4.00
2
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$2.55
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$1.70
1
View Close + Cart
#73 The High Dive
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
#74 Miraculous Escape
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$12.50
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$3.00
1
View Close + Cart
#75 Tracy Takes Fall
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good+ - 3.5
$10.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#76 Tracy is Rescued
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5
$13.50
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$4.00
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.70
1
View Close + Cart
#77 Tracy Lies in Wait
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
#78 Highway Hold-Up
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$7.25
1
View Close + Cart
#79 Gun Battle
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
$4.25
1
View Close + Cart
#80 The Flaming Wreck
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.00
2
View Close + Cart
#81 Still on the Trail
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
$24.00
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$4.00
1
View Close + Cart
#82 Key to the Mystery
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent+ - 4.5
$13.50
1
View Close + Cart
#84 Tracy Demands Speed
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$9.75
1
View Close + Cart
#86 Junior and Steve Arrive
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.50
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good+ - 3.5
$8.75
1
View Close + Cart
#88 Bad News for Steve
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$12.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$7.00
1
View Close + Cart
#89 Della Gets Instructions
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$8.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.70
1
View Close + Cart
#92 The Mysterious Shot
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$10.50
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.25
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.55
1
View Close + Cart
#93 Della an Innocent Victim
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
$30.00
1
View Close + Cart
#94 Murderous Death Weapon
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
$6.75
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$4.75
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$3.25
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$2.30
2
View Close + Cart
#95 Face to Face with Steve
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good+ - 3.5
$9.50
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$5.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$3.75
1
View Close + Cart
#96 Over the Cliff
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 3 - VG
$25.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$12.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$6.25
1
View Close + Cart
#97 In the Killer's Cell
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $100 
$90 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
#98 Steve Hires Crafty Lawyer
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $145 
$131 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
#99 Tracy Prepares for Trial
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
 $150 
$135 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Excellent - 5
 $94.00 
$89 after 5% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $62.00 
$59 after 5% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$18.00
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
#100 The State Versus Steve
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $82.00 
$78 after 5% discount
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$17.50
3
View Close + Cart
#101 The Plea for the Defense
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $140 
$126 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
#102 Sentenced for Life
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
PSA 4 - VG/EX
$30.50
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$18.00
1
View Close + Cart
#103 At the Penitentiary
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
 $200 
$180 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$43.00
1
View Close + Cart
#104 Convict No. 2017
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
 $115 
$104 after 10% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
 $51.00 
$48 after 5% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$33.50
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$14.50
1
View Close + Cart
#105 Take That Snarled Steve
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
 $61.00 
$58 after 5% discount
2
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$21.00
2
View Close + Cart
#106 Birds of Feather
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$17.00
2
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
$11.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
#107 Steve in Rage
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $70.00 
$67 after 5% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$24.00
2
View Close + Cart
#108 Stooge Viller's Trickery
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent - 5
$26.00
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$17.00
2
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$7.50
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$3.25
1
View Close + Cart
#109 Letter From Tracy
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Fair - 1.5
$26.00
1
View Close + Cart
#110 Junior Dreams
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $87.50 
$83 after 5% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good - 3
 $61.50 
$58 after 5% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$30.00
1
View Close + Cart
#111 Steve Lays His Plans
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Excellent/Mint - 6
$39.50
1
View Close + Cart
Very Good/Excellent - 4
$17.00
1
View Close + Cart
Good - 2
$7.50
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$5.00
1
View Close + Cart
Poor - 1
$3.25
1
View Close + Cart
#112 Steve's Treachery
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good - 3
 $99.00 
$94 after 5% discount
1
View Close + Cart
Fair - 1.5
$48.50
2
View Close + Cart
#113 Two Criminal Minds
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $58.50 
$56 after 5% discount
2
View Close + Cart
#114 Stooge Reveals His Plot
View All + Want
1937 Dick Tracy R41
Qty
View All + Want
Very Good/Excellent - 4
 $73.50 
$70 after 5% discount
2
View Close + Cart

Page : 1 2 Next >>

Dean's Cards® is a registered trademark of Dean's Cards, LLC. 2024

Report this card

Thank you for your report.

This dialog will close automatically.

Add To Cart Report
Please consider
leaving a review